I asked Dr. Lendemer to look at a similar specimen I found on the same tree (thinking it was Parmeliella appalachensis) and this is what he suggested. I looked back at this collection and realized it was the same thing. It is really hard to tell the difference from my photos though. I apologize for the constant shifting of my identifications.
Toms Curtis
2017-10-00
Sat Oct 28 2017 13:08:49 GMT-0400 (EDT)
United States of America, West Virginia, West Virginia, US